Buster
Keaton was the most cinematic of the silent comedians. He was
fascinated by film from the moment
he first stepped in front of a
camera. The dazzling Sherlock Junior (1924) is one of the most
cinematic films ever made in its use of special effects shots which
were well ahead of their time, only Keaton could have dreamed up the
scenario of the hero entering the screen and joining the action in the
film. Keaton's films took in the whole landscape while Chaplins focused
on the Tramp. Unlike Lloyd Keaton's grace and agility made dangerous
stunts look easy and he rarely used stuntmen. Keaton's little man was
also quite cynical with regard to women, though he attempts to help
them, they become more rewards for valour than real love objects in his
independent films, he never put women up in a pedestal like Chaplin and
Lloyd did. This lack of sentiment or overtly asking for sympathy made
Keaton less popular in his time though arguably more accessible today.
Buster was a vaudevillian from the age of three in an act with his
parents called The Three Keatons in which he was dubbed "the Human Mop"
and kicked about and thrown through scenery for comic effect. Early on
Buster recalled that he was the sort of comedian who registered bigger
laughs without a smile, so the Great Stone Face was born though in his
early shorts co-starring with good friend Roscoe "Fatty" Arbuckle he
can be seen smiling, laughing and crying.
In
1920 Buster started making a superb series of two reelers some of
which are among the funniest of his films : One Week
(1920), The High
Sign (1920), The Boat (1921) and Cops (1922). He made the transition to
features with Three Ages (1923) a parody of Griffith's Intolerance
(1916) which was like three two reelers spliced together though it had
its moments of surreal brilliance. Keaton liked parodying dramatic
films of the time and two of his greatest films are also period pieces
: Our Hospitality (1923) and The General (1927).
Unfortunately Buster was very much third in popularity among the silent
clowns in the silent era and lacked the business acumen of his rivals.
His films were produced by Joseph Schenck who Keaton trusted with money
matters. In 1928 after the delightful Steamboat Bill Junior (1928)
failed to cover its costs Schenck turned Buster over to MGM as a
contract player.
At first things didn't go too badly and there are classic moments in
both The Cameraman (1928) and Spite Marriage (1929) but already what
made Buster unique, his resourcefulness and view of the woman was being
eroded. Sound added to his problems, also a failing marriage and heavy
drinking. Keaton's voice was a slow drawl totally at odds with his
grace but the new rhythms of the talkie were also wrong for his
brilliant visual gags. MGM saddled him as well with wisecrack happy
writers and Jimmy Durante. He was finally fired in 1933.
Thankfully Keaton lived to see a revival in interest in his silent
films and kept busy until his death with film appearances, music hall
tours and TV. Buster was very popular with his co-workers and was a
fine director, his greatest films will continue to entertain us for
many years to come.
Buster Keaton Theme featured in
Spite Marriage (1929) :